1
MV-General Production / Using emphasis - sorry I can't remember who to credit for this repost.
« on: June 23, 2017, 09:12:50 pm »
Alright, folks, the results are in, and they are conclusive. For those of you don't want to read through all of the gory details, the bottom line is this:
To avoid any undesirable de-emphasis on your resamples, just keep the following in mind, and you'll be good to go:
1. When using "Re-sample": turn pre-emphasis and normalization ON.
2. When using "Re-sample Mix" to bounce internal tracks only: apply emphasis afterwords with "Sample Edit"
3. When using "Re-sample Mix" to record track(s) routed out and back in through the input: no emphasis needed.
4. When using "Sample Edit" to fix a sample that was de-emphasized: apply emphasis (not normalization).
Or just use the even shorter list:
1. Use your ears and see if emphasis has changed!
Now, for anyone interested in the gory details:
Re-sample Mix: this de-emphasizes the sample - NOT GOOD
Re-sample Mix (recording a track routed out and back in through the input): sample stays GOOD
Re-sampling with pre-emphasis off: de-emphasizes the sample - NOT GOOD
Re-sampling with pre-emphasis on: sample not de-emphasized, but gain significantly reduced - NOT GOOD
Re-sampling with pre-emphasis and normalization on: sample not de-emphasized or de-amplified - GOOD
Direct Recording analog out - to - analog in: sample not de-emphasized or de-amplified - GOOD
Direct Recording digital out - to - digital in: sample not de-emphasized or de-amplified - GOOD
The direct recording tests (both analog and digital) reveal that pre-emphasis gets applied on the way in, and de-emphasis on the way out. Now I get the behavior of all Roland samplers. It didn't get it until now.
A'Shad wrote:
Some people say the De-emphasis also applies to using the digital I/O as well, I can't say since re-sampling on the MV got real boring real quick.
If by this you meant that the samples were losing their clarity, then I can assure you that this was because you did not have pre-emphasis and normalization turned on. Turn them on and you'll see that the resampled signal does not lose any clarity.
There was another long thread about de-emphasis and distortion after normalizing and pre-emphasizing, but that was due to epmhasis being applied after normalization, which would cause clipping on any sampler, not just the MV. You have to normalize after applying emphasis to avoid distortion.
Sorry for the numerous updates. Keeping samples accurate is critical and I'm trying to keep it simple. The 3 guidelines at the top will keep your samples accurate and should allow you to resample with confidence.
Thank you, and happy resampling
Sent from my iPhone
To avoid any undesirable de-emphasis on your resamples, just keep the following in mind, and you'll be good to go:
1. When using "Re-sample": turn pre-emphasis and normalization ON.
2. When using "Re-sample Mix" to bounce internal tracks only: apply emphasis afterwords with "Sample Edit"
3. When using "Re-sample Mix" to record track(s) routed out and back in through the input: no emphasis needed.
4. When using "Sample Edit" to fix a sample that was de-emphasized: apply emphasis (not normalization).
Or just use the even shorter list:
1. Use your ears and see if emphasis has changed!
Now, for anyone interested in the gory details:
Re-sample Mix: this de-emphasizes the sample - NOT GOOD
Re-sample Mix (recording a track routed out and back in through the input): sample stays GOOD
Re-sampling with pre-emphasis off: de-emphasizes the sample - NOT GOOD
Re-sampling with pre-emphasis on: sample not de-emphasized, but gain significantly reduced - NOT GOOD
Re-sampling with pre-emphasis and normalization on: sample not de-emphasized or de-amplified - GOOD
Direct Recording analog out - to - analog in: sample not de-emphasized or de-amplified - GOOD
Direct Recording digital out - to - digital in: sample not de-emphasized or de-amplified - GOOD
The direct recording tests (both analog and digital) reveal that pre-emphasis gets applied on the way in, and de-emphasis on the way out. Now I get the behavior of all Roland samplers. It didn't get it until now.
A'Shad wrote:
Some people say the De-emphasis also applies to using the digital I/O as well, I can't say since re-sampling on the MV got real boring real quick.
If by this you meant that the samples were losing their clarity, then I can assure you that this was because you did not have pre-emphasis and normalization turned on. Turn them on and you'll see that the resampled signal does not lose any clarity.
There was another long thread about de-emphasis and distortion after normalizing and pre-emphasizing, but that was due to epmhasis being applied after normalization, which would cause clipping on any sampler, not just the MV. You have to normalize after applying emphasis to avoid distortion.
Sorry for the numerous updates. Keeping samples accurate is critical and I'm trying to keep it simple. The 3 guidelines at the top will keep your samples accurate and should allow you to resample with confidence.
Thank you, and happy resampling
Sent from my iPhone